State Farm® Insurance Agent Amy Tillotson

"After another insurance agency left my wife and I high and dry by not following through with what they agreed to we were able to get a very short extension our closing date. Or realtor immediately introduced us to Amy. Within 24 hours of our introduction to Amy, she and her staff provided us with an inclusive insurance policy for us to sign that was $2000 less than the other agency was able to unsuccessfully put together in over 2 months of working with them. The expediency of the work by Amy and her staff made it possible for us to be able to close on our dream vacation home. I recommend them with the highest marks."

"Amy, was great to work with! I called her yesterday and she had me a quote in one day. She was very professional and nice to work with!"

"We have been working with Amy for the last several years and have been completely happy. We just switched our auto insurance over with her and got a great rate and THE BEST customer service you can ask for. Amy and her team go out of their way to take care of you and to make everything as easy and stress free as possible. We will continue to stay with Amy and State Farm!"

"This is one of the best State Farm Agents we have found! She has great products, awesome knowledge and the know how to get things done. They have a product for every need. Most importantly the life insurance and investments are top notch and have been the most beneficial for our family and businesses! Thank you!"

"Courteous and very helpful. She was friendly and attended to my needs promptly. Very highly recommend."

"Very informative and helpful"

"Valerie is always super helpful and responds quickly! Thank you for always taking care of my insurance needs!"

"AMY is a great agent. She always has the time to help with policy issues. She is very kind and is very knowledgeable about insurance. Her office is the best one in town without a doubt."

"When my previous State Farm agent retired, I brought my needs to Amy Tillotson. Although we can now handle most of our own insurance issues on our smartphones, it’s so reassuring to have Amy and her caring and conscientious team sort out and resolve every detail. I have my auto, renters and umbrella policies with Amy and it gives me peace of mind to know whatever I need, Amy Tillotson and her team are there for me."

"Amy is super friendly, quick to respond, and is patient with me because I can be a lot sometimes! I sell insurance myself, just for different states, so I trust Amy and her staff and I would definitely recommend them to anyone."

"Our family has trusted Amy Tillotson for years. She consistently provides exceptional service, genuinely cares about her clients, and gives back to the community. I highly recommend Amy and her agency. Randy Rabon"

"Amy and Luellen are the best and most helpful agents around. The long term history of this agency is proof of the trust and confidence folks have in them. They always give the extra effort to provide service and answer questions."

"Thank you Amy Tillotson and LouEllen Wilson!! You guys take the time to explain our policies and options each time we visit your office. It is wonderful to talk with you in person!! “Like a good neighbor”, you are there!!
Just Wow!!!"

"Amy is a wonderful personality that is great to work with, I have only had positive experiences with her!"

""As a fellow business professional, I know exactly what top-tier performance looks like—and Amy Tillotson sets the standard. Her agency’s underwriting support for KHII 88.9FM Cloudcroft / 100.5 Alamogordo has been absolutely stellar. Amy and her team operate with a level of diligence and precision that is rare in today’s market. She doesn't just manage policies; she meticulously tailors' coverage to protect what matters most, making the process entirely frictionless. Amy combines a deep, technical mastery of risk assessment with incredibly efficient turnarounds, ensuring asset protection is handled seamlessly. Her deep roots in the Alamogordo and Cloudcroft communities shine through in her work ethic and dedication. Incredible communication, fast execution, and a true partner in local broadcasting. Her commitment to the Otero County community is matched only by her precision, reliability, and high-level performance. If you are looking for an agent who delivers accuracy, transparency, and elite service, Amy is the absolute best in the business. Five stars all the way!""

"Wow the service helping me fill out a claim was so professional and nice. They went out of their way to help me."

"I had a really great experience with this State Farm office. I recently moved to the area and was working through the process of getting my car insured, and they made everything incredibly easy. My situation was a little unique because my vehicle is a Toyota imported from Japan, so it’s not the typical car you see on the road here. Even with that, the team was patient, knowledgeable, and extremely helpful throughout the entire process.They took the time to answer my questions, walk me through my options, and made me feel completely comfortable with everything. Moving to a new place and figuring out things like insurance and vehicle registration can be stressful, but they honestly made it a lot easier for me. Everyone I spoke with was friendly, professional, and genuinely seemed happy to help. I really appreciate the time and effort they put into helping me get everything set up. Highly recommend this office if you’re looking for great customer service and people who actually care about helping you."

"The whole team is extremely polite and wonderful to work with very professional."

"Amy Tillotson State Farm Insurance has been my go to insurance company for almost 30 years! Amy’s team goes above and beyond supporting their clients. Today, Amy worked with me to help my daughter get insurance on a new car! Thank you Amy Tillotson State Farm for doing the great job you do!"

"I switched from AAA to State Farm for all my insurance. Home, Auto, Life. Not only have I saved $499.63 a month. I have half the deductible I did before and I have double the coverage. !!! As a bonus her office supports veteran organizations in Alamogordo."

"We love Amy and her team! They go above and beyond in order to ensure that their clients are cared for! Not only are we confidently covered in our home, car, and life insurance, Amy and her team helped us with a travel ID emergency during our recent trip to NYC. The slogan “State Farm is There” is quite accurate. Thank you, Amy!"

"Great people and services. Always friendly and ready to help you with all your insurance needs."

"Amy has been our agent for the past four years...wish we had discovered her 20 years ago .. fantastic service"

"Everyone is so efficient and professional. Thank you for being nice and helpful!"

"They really do go above and beyond to find you the best rate possible at a very fair price; and they don't try to upsell you thing's you don't need. The customer service was exceptional on every level. I am glad I made the decision to go with a hometown agency where I can either walk in and get information or call and get information whenever I need it. Great agency. There is a reason they have so many 5 star reviews."